Civility, silence, and the cost of keeping quiet
by: Rev. Anna Golladay
Every election season, a familiar sermon gets preached. Sometimes it comes from the pulpit. More often it comes from the family group text or the friend group: Keep the peace. Don’t make everything political. Just be nice.
I understand the impulse. I’ve felt it myself. We are tired of shouting, tired of losing friends over yard signs, tired of not being able to share an opinion without judgment. But I’ve been sitting with the Hebrew prophets this fall, and I have to be honest with you. I wish we cared a little more about honesty than we do about being polite.
Amos wasn’t a religious leader. He was a shepherd and caretaker of a fig field. On a walk to Bethel, he talks about what he was seeing…almost like his own private video blog. People were being sold out “for silver, and the poor for a pair of shoes” (Amos 2:6). The worship was holy, but he thought justice was missing. God, he said, would rather have justice: “let judgment run down as waters, and righteousness as a mighty stream” (Amos 5:24).

Isaiah told a group that had gathered to worship that their prayers were not being heard, because their hands were doing harm. He could have said this with a more polite tone, but instead he opted for blatant honesty in the form a list: seek justice, relieve the oppressed, defend the orphan, plead for the widow (Isaiah 1:15–17).
Micah gave us the verse that many of us recite by heart: do justly, love mercy, walk humbly with your God (Micah 6:8). But I wonder how many times we read the chapters before and after the verse. Because that’s where he actually calls out the leaders who profit off their people.
None of them were mean. But none of them kept the peace by staying quiet.
Here is the distinction I think we’ve lost. Kindness is how we speak. Silence is whether we speak at all. Somewhere along the way, we started treating them as the same virtue.
Kindness is a gift. It means I speak to you as someone made in the image of God. I don’t mock you, I don’t lie about you, and I don’t treat you as an enemy to be destroyed. Scripture asks this of us, although many of our public figures seem to have forgotten.
But when “civility” means never naming harm, it stops being a virtue and becomes a muzzle. It protects whoever is comfortable with the way things are. When people are suffering, they aren’t thinking about our kindness. They are thinking about our silence.
The prophets were courteous in the deepest sense. They told the truth to people because they believed those people could still find God. Silence, on the other hand, quietly assumes the powerful can’t change and the vulnerable can wait.
There is a part in Amos that always makes me think. When Amos got pushback, it didn’t come from the king initially. It came from a priest, Amaziah. He was the one who told Amos to get out of there and do his prophesying someplace else. Leave it to the religious establishment to ask for politics to not be introduced in church.
That request has a long history. Dr. King wrote from a Birmingham jail that his deepest disappointment was not the open segregationists. It was the moderate who valued order over justice and kept counseling patience to people who had been patient for generations. Many of those moderates were sitting in pews.
Silence has a cost, yes. But the question is “who pays it?” It’s usually not paid for by those who are waiting for the silence to break.
None of us are Amos. But we can practice what he practiced. Here are a few ways to do that in the weeks ahead.
- Name the harm, not the person’s worth. Say plainly what a policy does to real people. Start with what you’ve seen. Amos spoke about markets and courts he had actually walked through. Tell the story of a neighbor, a classroom, a clinic.
- Ask the Micah question out loud. In your small group, your Sunday school class, your dinner conversations, ask: Is this just? Is this merciful? Is this humble? Let the question do some of the work.
- Make room for the people most affected. The prophets spoke for the widow and the orphan. It is better, if possible, to allow marginalized communities to speak for themselves. Find space for that platform.
- Stay at the table. Keep showing up to the relationships where the hard conversations happen.
- Act, not just speak. Isaiah’s list was made of verbs. Make a plan to vote, check your polling location, and offer a neighbor a ride.
The prophets were not silent, but they were faithful. They loved their people too much to shield the truth, and they loved God too much to pretend injustice was something to ignore.
So as this season grows louder, I’m not asking you to grow radical or forceful. I’m asking you to be honest. Speak with kindness. Speak with humility. But speak.

