The Crisis of Attention: Why Congregations Must Become Schools of Contemplation

In CPR Connects by camerontrimbleLeave a Comment

Congregations can help us recover the attention that makes compassion possible.

By Rev. Cameron Trimble, CEO of Convergence

We’re all guilty of checking the weather on our phone and then finding ourselves scrolling through a whole load of news and videos we didn’t intend to. Twenty minutes later we’ve completely lost track of time. Even after putting the phone down and getting back to what we were doing, a large part of our brain is still in that state of distraction. We all know what that feels like. It’s there in the meeting, it’s there in the conversation, and it’s there in the very quiet moments when we were hoping to just be relaxed.

Digital platforms are always fighting for our attention and AI now plays a huge part in determining what information we see. They shape what we notice and what we don’t.

A 2025 Pew Research Center survey found that 36% of American teens use at least one of the five major social media platforms almost constantly. Nearly two thirds use an AI chatbot. That’s a massive amount of digital engagement in the daily lives of teens, though the survey doesn’t prove that the technology is the cause of their lack of focus.

Photo by Micael Sáez on Unsplash

I wonder what all this means for our spiritual lives. When someone shares something painful, can we really listen? When a prayer makes us uncomfortable, do we let that feeling teach us before moving on? These are common moments in congregational life, and they require a kind of attention that busy days regularly leave us unprepared to give.

Attention Is a Moral and Spiritual Question

In The World Beyond Your Head, philosopher Matthew B. Crawford looks at how attention shapes our freedom and sense of self. He encourages us to think about the environments that guide our attention, including businesses that compete for it.

This question also involves the church. Congregations shape environments as well. We teach people what to believe about God and how to read sacred texts. We set the pace of worship and decide how much space conversations get. Through these choices, we are already teaching people about attention. How regularly do we pause to think about what they are learning?

In a letter to poet Joë Bousquet of 1942 Simone Weil wrote: “Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.” To attend to someone is to make space for their experience, including what is disturbing and what asks of us.

Think about the difference between being genuinely listened to and being pushed towards a solution. You’ll spot that difference immediately. There will be a moment when someone has actually taken the time to listen and you’ll find yourself with words for things you didn’t really understand at all. That’s the power of attention. It’s an attention that asks you to set aside your own agenda and be open to being transformed by the person you’re talking to. Weil’s notion of generosity is exactly that. It’s also why attention is such a vital ingredient in compassion. You have to be present long enough to work out what love actually asks of us.

The Difference Between Information and Wisdom

Neuroscientist Amishi Jha’s work offers some hope in this area. In a series of six studies with military personnel (published online in 2021), mindfulness training was found to help people maintain their working memory under stress, as opposed to those who didn’t receive the training.

This is about a mental skill rather than spiritual development per se. That said I’m quite encouraged by the idea that practice can help us retain those skills when life gets tough. It makes you wonder what kind of thing could be achieved through regular practice in a congregation over time.

We already know how to give people more information. AI can distill a theological argument in the space of seconds and our churches are full of books, classes and sermons. The problem is that even if we know a great deal about forgiveness, we may still find it difficult to listen to someone who has hurt us. That’s where wisdom comes in. It’s applying what we know in the difficult bits of life. Proverbs gives us the guidance to do this by listening, by observing and by paying attention to the consequences of what we do.

Recovering Our Relationship with the World

Sociologist Hartmut Rosa talks about a society which is always in a state of growth and of speed. In Resonance, he looks at the quality of our relationship to the world, the extent to which we are open to what we experience, to responding to it and to the possibility of change. Those are moments which depend on a certain openness which you can’t force and which you can’t control.

We tend to measure the health of a congregation in terms of attendance, the number of programs, the level of volunteering and the amount of donations. All of those things are important, but they don’t really tell us anything about whether people are growing in their relationship with the holy. We can have a worship service full of announcements and a meeting full of business and still have very little space for reflection.

I think many clergy will be familiar with that tension. We want our communities to be healthy, and we always have more to do. Reflection can start to seem like something we’ll get to once all the pressing things have been dealt with. The tempo at which we live our lives is going to have a huge bearing on the experience of church for people. Does our life together provide people with the time to notice what is going on in themselves and in the world around them? Do we allow sufficient time for an encounter to have an effect?

What the Mystics Understood

This is one reason I am drawn to the mystical tradition. Its teachers believe that meeting the sacred can change how we see things. Meister Eckhart questioned fixed ideas about God. Hildegard of Bingen paid attention to the living presence in creation. Julian of Norwich stayed with questions about suffering and divine love. Their work invites us to spend time with experiences we might otherwise rush past.

Matthew Fox brings the tradition into the present day through Creation Spirituality. His four paths are: wonder and gratitude (Via Positiva), silence and suffering (Via Negativa), creativity (Via Creativa) and justice and compassion (Via Transformativa).

I think these paths are so valuable in bringing the various elements of spiritual life together. Wonder enables us to see the beauty of creation and reminds us of our responsibility to care for it. Grief teaches us to be present even when we can’t fix or make sense of what has occurred. Creativity gives us means of response and compassion allows that response to be lived in the lives of others. A congregation can be a place where people learn to do this together, gradually learning to trust that paying attention will in fact ask something of them.

Becoming Communities That Cultivate Attention

What would that look like in the life of the congregation? I think it’s both practical and meaningful. We don’t need new buildings, we don’t need expensive programs, we don’t need all sorts of complex lesson plans. We can simply look at how our existing practices are going to shape the attention of everyone present.

We could start with the reclamation of true silence. A lot of churches are uncomfortable with silence, I think largely because it gives the impression that nothing is going on. A few minutes of genuine silence during worship can be an opportunity to become aware of our breathing, our bodies, our feelings and our environment. Silence should never be a test of spiritual achievement. People will experience stillness in different ways and some will find movement or some other form of embodied prayer more to their liking. The point is simply to create space in which attention can settle and deepen.

A second practice involves learning to listen without immediately responding. Imagine congregational gatherings in which participants consistently participate in structured listening exercises. One person speaks for several minutes while another hears without interrupting, offering advice, or preparing a rebuttal. The listener then reflects back what they heard before offering their own perspective. This simple discipline has the ability to transform the quality of communal relationships. It also prepares people for the difficult work of dialogue across theological, cultural, and political differences.

We could also recover the practice of slow reading. Christian traditions have long used lectio divina, a contemplative approach to sacred texts that involves reading, reflection, prayer, and silence. Similar forms of sustained engagement can be adapted for interfaith communities and applied to poetry, spiritual writings, and even carefully chosen contemporary issues. Instead of approaching every text as material to master or debate, participants learn to notice what unsettles them, what awakens curiosity, and what stimulates further reflection.

Another possibility is to extend contemplative attention beyond the sanctuary. Congregations might organize neighborhood walks in which participants intentionally observe their surroundings. What signs of beauty and flourishing do they notice? Where is the community experiencing neglect or suffering? Whose labor sustains the neighborhood? Whose stories remain unheard? Such practices help connect contemplation with ecological awareness, economic justice, and community transformation. They remind us that paying attention to the sacred also involves paying attention to the material conditions of human life.

Photo by Javardh on Unsplash

Finally, congregations could bring contemplative discernment into their leadership and decision-making. Before moving immediately into budgets, strategic plans, and organizational concerns, boards and ministry teams might begin with a period of reflection. What are we noticing in our community? What assumptions are shaping our interpretation of events? Whose voices are absent from this conversation? What might we be overlooking because we are anxious to reach a decision? These questions can create room for deeper collective wisdom to emerge.

None of these practices require a congregation to abandon their beliefs or their ways of worship. They are simply about helping the community to focus on something which has always been at the heart of spiritual life; the growth of human awareness.

These practices also make us think again about what good religious leadership means. Maybe one of the most important jobs for spiritual leaders today is to help people notice where their attention is going, what is shaping it, and how they can reclaim it to direct attention to what truly brings life.

An Invitation to Become More Fully Awake

The people whose suffering we see in the news today will still be in need of care long after the headlines have moved on. I keep coming back to that. Our attention is so easily drawn elsewhere, yet grief, loss and the work of recovery continues. A community that enables us to stay present can be a community that supports a commitment we may not be able to make on our own.

We need spaces in which hard questions can be asked, in which grief can be heard and in which wonder doesn’t have to demonstrate its value. The church has centuries of contemplative wisdom to draw on and the opportunity every week to live that out. We can begin with simply listening to a neighbor’s story, making space in a meeting or simply praying together when we don’t know what to say. Over time those choices will shape the community we become and may well help us to see where God is already inviting us to respond.

An invitation to Journeying with the Mystics

Convergence is exploring this ancient wisdom today through Journeying with the Mystics: 24 Sessions of Spiritual Awakening, featuring Matthew Fox and other spiritual teachers. This series invites people to rediscover contemplative traditions that have helped generations find wonder, courage, compassion, and a deeper sense of the sacred. Together, we will see how these old practices can help us meet today’s challenges and become more present to the world we are called to love.

References

Pew Research Center

Faverio, Michelle, and Olivia Sidoti. “Teens, Social Media and AI Chatbots 2025.” December 9, 2025. Survey of 1,458 U.S. teens ages 13–17. Source

Matthew B. Crawford The World Beyond Your Head: On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2015 (paperback, 2016). Source

Simone Weil. Letter to Joë Bousquet, April 13, 1942, in Correspondance (L’Âge d’Homme, 1982), p. 18. Quotation and original French reproduced in Lara Zammit, “Footnotes and Finitude,” Melita Theologica 70, no. 2 (2020), p. 199, note 1. Source

Amishi P. Jha and colleagues Jha, Amishi P., Anthony P. Zanesco, Ekaterina Denkova, William K. MacNulty, and Scott L. Rogers. “The Effects of Mindfulness Training on Working Memory Performance in High-Demand Cohorts: a Multi-study Investigation.” Journal of Cognitive Enhancement 6, no. 2, pp. 192–204. Published online November 24, 2021. Source

Hartmut Rosa Resonance: A Sociology of Our Relationship to the World. Translated by James C. Wagner. Polity, 2019. Source

Matthew Fox Original Blessing: A Primer in Creation Spirituality. Author’s overview of the four paths of Creation Spirituality. Source

Leave a Comment